Tomb Raider: Who would play the new Lara Croft?

That's_no_Angelina

The previous Lara Croft was perfectly expressed by casting Angelina Jolie for the Tomb Raider movies. Larger than life, iconic, aglow with celebrity, handy with pistols, plastically unreal.

The new Lara Croft is none of those thing. This Lara Croft is small and girlish, with a pony tail instead of the previous tightly practical braid. She looks more likely to raid a library than a tomb (she even claims to hate tombs at one point). She’s smart and competent, but aware of her limitations. She expresses self-doubt, grief, confusion, anguish, and pain. She runs out of breath. She is not a superman. She is cold, wet, dirty, and sometimes wounded. Indiana Jones might get his knuckles scraped up before the scene is over, but he — and Nathan Drake, by the way — is defined by swagger and confidence. He has no self-doubt, only the grim resignation and acceptance that befits a stoically invulnerable character. See also, pre-Skyfall James Bond.

So if this Tomb Raider reboot were made into a movie, the new Lara Croft wouldn’t just be someone famous. She certainly wouldn’t be just another model. She would have to express something new for the series and it seems to me Crystal Dynamics had someone in mind.

After the jump, is it as obvious to you as it is to me?

Anna Kendrick exudes intelligence and competence, but she’s also got a sense of vulnerability and girlishness that isn’t just the usual ingenue-ity. And I can’t imagine that the artists at Crystal Dynamics aren’t aware of the visual similarities.

LC2

LC3

LC4

It’s not just me, right?

Tomorrow: real horror show
Click here for the previous Tomb Raider entry.

  • Pogue Mahone

    This is probably where I would put the “don’t know if serious” Joker gif, were that possible on the front page.

  • Brandon

    Aca-tastic!

  • http://twitter.com/jdhas jdhas

    Are you kidding me? Obviously Jennifer Lawrence is the perfect actor for this new version of Lara Croft.

  • ScottDobros

    Oh Tom…

  • CB

    Can’t say I was surprised, but you still got a soft chuckle out of me.

  • Morningoil

    I don’t know who Anna Kendrick is. This may be an unfortunate thing. As it happens, it is indeed Jennifer Lawrence.

  • Wolfox

    Two words: Camilla Luddington.

  • Chris H.

    Based on the screenshot you posted, Tom, I absolutely thought “Kendrick”. Soo..did you chop that screenie to look like her? ;)

  • Wholly Schmidt

    Totally knew you were going to say Anna Kendrick, and not just because you love Anna Kendrick (as everyone should). But I see the Jennifer Lawrence argument too. And Daniel Day-Lewis

  • Soma

    I think Tom is having a crush on either the new Lara or Anna. Or both. Typo police bulletin: “pratical braid” in paragraph 2 should be “practical braid” instead.

  • amanda_chen

    Emily Booth?

  • SadleyBradley

    I was getting more of an Olivia Thirlby vibe myself.

  • saltiness

    I’m sorry but Denzel Washington would fit this character archtype perfectly.

  • Nightgaunt

    I take exception to your description of Indiana Jones. When I rewatched the movies recently, I was struck by how consistently he fails, makes a mistake (can’t find the basket with Marion), gets caught, gets duped (poison in Hong Kong), and makes desperate guesses. Once I started paying attention, it seemed failure really was the engine that made things tick, which makes some sense in a “cliffhanger” genre. Sure, Indiana Jones will sometimes feign confidence, but unlike some of the early James Bonds, he doesn’t swagger his way through life doing all the right things without thinking.

    Not sure I agree either with the Anna Kendrick thing. Well, not the casting choice. I do agree that she’s super-awesome.

  • tomchick

    I’m also a Jennifer Lawrence fan — who isn’t? — but I’m going to need to see some comparison pictures for you guys to convince me. I just don’t get as much of a Jennifer Lawrence vibe from playing the game. Show me where she looks like the new Lara Croft.

  • tomchick

    Oh, Indiana Jones definitely isn’t as invulnerable as James Bond. And you have a good point about his occasional missteps. But I still think he’s characterized by swagger and confidence. Most male action heroes are. Even John McClane, who represented a shift from invulnerability to vulnerability in 80s action movies, is all about swagger and wisecracking.

  • tomchick

    Ah, good call. I like this pick.

  • tomchick

    While I certainly enjoyed looking up who Emily Booth is, I have to say she’d be a better fit for the old Lara Croft.

  • tomchick

    Cheers for the correction!

  • tomchick

    So I knew she was the voice actress for the new Lara Croft — and she does an excellent job — but now that I’ve seen pictures of her, I think you’re right. It looks like Crystal Dynamics also used her as visual inspiration.

    So much for my Anna Kendrick theory. :(

  • http://www.facebook.com/rjellinghaus Rob Jellinghaus

    http://popwatch.ew.com/2013/02/26/tomb-raider-camilla-luddington/ is mighty interesting. They had Camilla play the game so they could record her own gasps and sharp inhalations as she experienced herself getting beaten about in the game. That’s somewhere between creepy and genius.

  • greatatlantic

    OK, I had to look her up, since her name wasn’t ringing any bells. The only movie I’ve seen with her in it was the Scott Pilgrim conversion. Her character in that one is very different then this “new” Laura Croft you describe.

  • tomchick

    I prescribe viewings of Rocket Science, Up in the Air, End of Watch, and especially Pitch Perfect. The Twilight movies are optional.

  • Mercanis

    “Ingenue-ity”. Ooo, I like that!

  • http://twitter.com/clwheeljack Charles Wheeler

    Tom, your Anna Kendrick thing is getting a little out of hand.

  • http://www.facebook.com/erik.kjellquist Erik Kjellquist

    When I first saw the original cinematic, I was actually thinking Jewel Staite

  • greatatlantic

    Hmm… that is more movies than I watch in a month, so I’ll just pick one. You say Pitch Perfect is the best of the lot? That sounds like a good option. I do like a good baseball movie.

  • JustAGuy

    Didn’t play the new Tomb raider, so I don’t know what new Lara is like, but you basically described Jennifer Lawrence’s character from Hunger games.

  • Dustrunner

    Ok, I think Olivia Munn is probably a terrible actress compared to Kendrick.. but she really does look like the new Lara. http://cdn01.cdn.justjared.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/05/munn-uganda/olivia-munn-uganda-project-fundrasier-with-jason-ritter-04.jpg

  • Andy Bates

    Denzel Washington! I knew this new Lara Croft looked familiar!

  • R Agsa

    It’s funny how a lot of people were complaining when they saw the picture of Jennifer Lawrence as Katniss Everdeen. They even went as far as saying that she looked more like the young Lara Croft than Katniss Everdeen when they compared the pictures. I happen to agree that she did and this role was specifically made for our Katniss Everdeen, Jennifer Lawrence as Lara Croft.

  • Robert Rossney

    Uhh, didn’t you mean “piratical?”